Could you pls include me? Thanks!
Could you pls include me? Thanks!
Would love to hear your thoughts! Tagging
@jvoth.bsky.social @essobecker.bsky.social @saumjha.bsky.social @nathannunn.bsky.social
@david-schindler.de @dinapomeranz.bsky.social
@hmmlowe.bsky.social @vcharnysh.bsky.social @guoxu.bsky.social @heycheckthisout.bsky.social
Full paper: ssrn.com/abstract=5007109
Want a quick overview? Check out this 12-min AI-generated podcast!
podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/guo...
See more on my website: gjiang-economics.github.io
#EconJobMarket
π¨ Why this matters: π¨
When govts ask citizens to contribute, perceived fairness is essential - not optional. See a recent example in Ukraine (www.reuters.com/world/europe...)
This is why inclusive institutions that treat everyone fairly are crucial (as the 2024 econ Nobel laureates argue)
[8/8]
How large is the impact?
If the draft had been fair (no poorer-richer draft gap), volunteering would've jumped approximate 1/3!!
[7/8]
Endogeneity?
Instrumental var: lottery number gaps between individuals' poorer vs richer neighbors π² π²
(Random lottery nums, lower = higher draft chance)
Higher nums for richer neighbors (in B's circle) β‘οΈ fewer richer drafted β‘οΈ bigger poorer-richer draft rate gap
[6/8]
2οΈβ£ Did the lower drafting of higher-income neighbors affect volunteering?
Main spec:
βΆοΈ Dependent var: binary indicator for individual volunteering
βΆοΈ Independent var: draft rate gap between individuals' poorer vs richer neighbors
[5/8]
For example:
βΆοΈ Doctor connections β‘οΈ 11% higher health exemptions
βΆοΈ The richer had more doctor connections
If lower drafting of the rich was observed, esp. among neighbors, it was perceived as unfair
[4/8]
1οΈβ£ These fairness concerns in Gallup polls were well-founded:
βΆοΈ Highest income group's draft rate = *half* that of lowest income group
βΆοΈ Rich more likely to get exemptions
Their exemptions? More questionable...
[3/8]
Key context:
βΆοΈ 12 million draftees and 6 million volunteers during WW2
βΆοΈ 20% of Gallup respondents perceived the draft as unfair
βΆοΈ Main complaints: βfavoritismβ, βmoney talksβ, and βsome use pull to get out of draftβ
Based on newly digitized military records, I show π§΅
[2/8]
π¨ Job Market Paper π¨
If 6 million individuals *voluntarily* put themself in a life-and-death situation, what drove them to make that choice?
My job market paper examines how perceived fairness affected the decision to voluntarily enlist in the US during WW2 #EconJMP #EconJMC #EconTwitter
[1/8]