The Pie Fairy 🥧

Apollo Third Birthday

Birthday of the Dead

Cocoa Nib Cheesecake

Green Fairy Cake

When running a small, virtual bakery, we often get the opportunity to make someone's dessert dreams come true. We try to do our very best to make something one-of-a-kind and delicious!

The following are our nominees for "Best Custom". Tune in tomorrow on Pi Day to see our winners revealed! 🥧🧚‍♀️🎂

Good morning @thepiefairy.bsky.social

Lemon Poppyseed Cookies, with special guest Chef Mario

Happy Mar10 Day! There's still time to order Pie Fairy delivery this weekend, so LET'S-A-GO! 🥧🧚🍄

We've got plenty of room for your deliveries this Friday and Saturday. And don't forget! Pi(e) Day is Saturday, March 14th, when we will reveal the winners of this year's Fairies Awards! 🥧🧚‍♀️🏆

Peach Tea Cookies

🍑 Peach Tea Cookies: The paragon of Southern Hospitality, filled with fresh peach jam, and topped with Earl Grey Tea Icing.

Lemon Poppyseed Cookies

🍋 Lemon Poppyseed Cookies: A crumbly crunchy streusel top, drizzled with lemon icing, over a sweet lemon and poppyseed sugar cookie.

Banana Bread Cookies

🍌 Banana Bread Cookies: Made with toasted walnuts, old-fashioned oats, and a drizzle of Mexican vanilla icing.

Cookies come from a batch of dough, portioned and measured and decorated individually, with the understanding that the next one will be just as good as the last. Cookies are a promise: I love you this much, now and tomorrow.

Here are the nominees for the Fairies Award for "Best Cookie":

Cantanada Pie

London Fog Pie

Dubai Pie

Fix Your Heart Cheesecake

A week from yesterday is Pi Day, and a week from today are The Oscars, so if you're looking for award-winning circular foods, look no further!

Delivery slots are wide open this week/end. DM us today! 🥧🧚🍿

The March Pie Fairy Menu

However you decide to celebrate your Pi(e) Day, or your Oscar's party, for that matter, know that we've got you covered! Tune in on Pi(e) Day -- Saturday, March 14th! -- to see who takes home the win! 🥧🧚‍♀️🏆

Cherry Cannoli Pie

🍒 Cherry Cannoli Pie: Cannoli cookie crumb crust, sweet cherries, ricotta mousse, topped with toasted pistachios and chocolate ganache. February's Pie of the Month!

Hummingbird Pie

Joining us to present the award this year:

🍍 Hummingbird Pie: Banana and spiced pecan frangipane with pineapple swirl, in a vanilla sable crust, topped with whip and pineapple. March's Pie of the Month!

Cantanada Pie

🥭 Cantanada Pie: Inspired by the chamoyadas of South O. Vanilla sable crust, cantaloupe custard, topped with Tajin whip and homemade sweet-and-spicy chamoy.

London Fog Pie

🫖 London Fog: The surprise hit of the year. Vanilla sable crust, Earl Grey tea mousse, white chocolate whipped ganache, and candied lavender buds.

Dubai Pie

🍫 Dubai Pie: You couldn't throw a rock without hitting some Dubai chocolate last year. Chocolate crumb crust, pistachio mousse, topped with toasted kataifi, ganache, and gold leaf chocolate pistachio candies.

Fix Your Heart Cheesecake

❤️‍🩹 Fix Your Heart Cheesecake: Directed by David Lynch, this vanilla and sage cheesecake-filled chocolate crumb crust is topped with cherry gelee and chocolate and vanilla whip chevron.

Fix Your Heart Cheesecake

Dubai Pie

London Fog

Cantanada Pie

It's a very special March pie round-up post as we proudly present to you the nominees for the 2026 Fairies Award for "Best Pie"! These four pies represent the best of the best of last year, as judged by YOU with your orders, reorders, comments, likes, and shares. Let's take a look!

Hummingbird Pie

We here at The Pie Fairy specialize in what we call "pieification"-- the creation of pie inspired by not-pie. To celebrate March, the most sacred month of Pi(e), I set my sights on the delicious Jamaican recipe of Hummingbird Cake. Hummingbird Cake, often believed to be from the American South, actually stems from a Jamaican tourism push in 1968. Then known as "Doctor Bird Cake", it was named after an indigenous hummingbird variety in Jamaica that apparently opted for medical school over The Arts. 🙃

Slice of Hummingbird Pie

The recipe for Doctor Bird Cake resonated with bakers in the South, often popping up at state and county fairs. Today, it still features many signature flavors and ingredients of Jamaica, and serves as yet another testament to our country's "melting pot" strength. Our Hummingbird Pie features a spiced banana-pecan frangipane filling, a vanilla sable short crust, and dots of pineapple and whipped cream. We hope this pie brings you a taste of a tropical spring. We would love to celebrate the greatness of pie with you this month: send us a message to secure your delivery! 🥧🧚🇯🇲

A little more about the March Pie of the Month, the Hummingbird Pie:

A slice of Hummingbird Pie

We have availability for deliveries this Thursday and Friday, and all next week. Message us today to lock in your delivery date! 🥧🧚‍♀️🥇

Creamsicle Pie

We don't usually feature too many of our classics, but the tangelos are just SO GOOD right now, I'd be silly not to point out our Creamsicle Pie: tangelo custard, graham cracker crumb crust, whip and zest.

Asian Pear Tatin Cookies

Continuing our pieification, presenting the Cookie of the Month, Asian Pear Tatin Cookies! Cinnamon-spiced sugar cookies filled with caramelized Asian pear.

Hummingbird Pie

Our Pie of the Month is the new Hummingbird Pie -- the pieification of the classic Hummingbird Cake -- featuring a sable shortbread crust, spiced banana-pecan frangipane, pineapple swirl, and dotted with whipped cream.

The Pie Fairy's March 2026 menu!

Hello, Pie Pals and Cookie Monsters! Welcome to March! Home of our favorite awards -- including The 2nd Annual Fairies Awards! -- and the most mathematically perfect holiday of the year -- Pi(e) Day on Saturday, March 14th! Let's take a look at our SUPERSIZED menu for the month!

The Second Annual Fairy Awards are coming soon! Stay tuned!

Deliveries this weekend are wide open, so send us a message and tell us what you are craving! 🥧🧚⏳

Jamu-Rang Pie

Laissez Linzer Cookies

Banana Bread Cookies

Chai Gingersnap Cookies

This is your LAST CALL for these cookies and this pie, while we get ready for Pi Day (Saturday, March 14th, of course!) and the unveiling of the nominees for our Second Annual Fairy Awards!

Fix Your Heart Cheesecake

Happy Twin Peaks Day!

(Black coffee sold separately.)
🥧🧚☕

Quiche Lorraine w/ Bacon & Caramelized Onions

Spinach & Mushroom Quiche

We've got prime delivery times available all weekend, so send us a DM and let us do (most of) the cooking! 🥧🧚‍♀️🌬️

Corned Beef & Cabbage Pot Pie

Chili & Cinnamon Roll Pot Pie

Our Take-n-Bake Pot Pies and Quiches are a great excuse to run the oven on a cold day, fill your house with delicious smells, and get some warm food in your tummy, while you await Actual Spring (approximately 3-5 days long).

The Seasons of Nebraska: Winter Fool's Spring Second Winter Spring of Deception Third Winter *(you are here) The Pollening Actual Spring Summer Hell's Front Porch False Fall Second Summer Fall

Hello to those of you just joining us in Nebraska! We'd like to make sure you're prepared for the third and final winter of the year, coming this weekend!

Chai Gingersnap Cookies

Le menu

🫖 Chai Gingersnap: Roasty, toasty spices! Classic chewy gingersnaps, kicked up with homemade chai spice!

Our Valentine's Day delivery window is closing soon! Send us a DM and get some fresh-baked love delivered to your door this week! 🥧🧚‍♀️💝