What to conclude when you read this in a paper's" acknowledgements section: "This paper has been reviewed by X, Y and Z. We thank X and Z for their constructive comments." 🤔
#reviewer2 ⚒️ 🧪
7
0
0
0
#Reviewer2
Latest posts tagged with #Reviewer2 on Bluesky
Trending
#U.S. Foreign Policy
#F1
#Chinese Grand Prix
#SNL
#Venezuela Baseball
#AEW Collision
#Six Nations
#Newcastle United
#Arsenal vs Everton
#Trump and Epstein
#U.S. Foreign Policy
#F1
#Chinese Grand Prix
#SNL
#Venezuela Baseball
#AEW Collision
#Six Nations
#Newcastle United
#Arsenal vs Everton
#Trump and Epstein
Posts tagged #Reviewer2
Imagine thinking the path to fault tolerance is just a larger purchase order from Bluefors.
#QuantumComputing #Reviewer2 #FaultTolerance
0
0
0
0
When Reviewer 2 asks for experimental verification but your circuit depth is already double the device's coherence limit.
#NISQ #QuantumComputing #Reviewer2
0
0
0
0
The O(polylog n) scaling looks great in the preprint until the classical baseline and a 98% gate fidelity show up to ruin your day. Latest QC papers: qubitsok.com/papers
#NISQ #QuantumComputing #Reviewer2
0
0
0
0
Nothing ruins a perfectly good NISQ paper like a reviewer asking for a side-by-side comparison with a laptop from 2018.
#QuantumAdvantage #NISQ #Reviewer2
0
0
0
0
Via @antoinevernet.com
#AcademicSky #reviewer2 #humot
2
1
0
0
There is a special place in hell for reviewers who ask for more revisions after you've done everything they originally asked of you #Reviewer2 #academia #polisky
5
0
0
0
I just got minor R&R back for a paper that had major issues and that I spent ALL of the fall revising.
It was honestly the hardest revision I've ever had but also the most fun and intellectually rewarding, and....
I might cry bc the reviewers validated my hard work. #AcademicSky #Reviewer2
7
0
0
0
According to nLab, Eilenberg & Mac Lane 1945, `General theory of natural equivalences', introducing categories, functors and natural transformations, was at first rejected on the grounds of having "no content"
#Reviewer2
ncatlab.org/nlab/show/ca...
0
0
1
0
He who fights with #Reviewer2 should look to it that he himself does not become a #Reviewer2. And if you gaze long into a reviewer’s comments, the reviewer’s comments also gaze into you.
0
0
0
0
12
0
1
0
4
1
0
0
Et tu n'es même pas #Reviewer2 !
1
0
1
0
This is v funny!
#Reviewer2 #AcademicLife
👇
2
1
0
0
It’s part of our mantra! Nurture. Don’t suffocate an author’s voice. #reviewer2
6
2
0
0
Wow. It didn't take long for the #Trump effect to infiltrate the #reviewer2 space. I just had a paper rejected for daring to (implicitly) assume in a #SOTL paper that white people aren't intrinsically smarter than black people. 😡
0
0
0
0
Submitted my R&R. I spent more time addressing reviewer 2. My article argues that public administration is now an admin of the public by the executive. Loyalty checks and exploitation trump service. I was told I was ill informed and that the USG is functioning fine. #reviewer2 #edusky
1
0
1
0
An image titled "The Peer Review Process." The Left pane shows a smiling man with the caption "First of all, great work." The right pane shows the same man with a skeptical look with a stack of papers labeled "My publications" in front of him and the caption "Second of all...interesting choice not to cite my work."
Don't mind me, I'm just over here trying not to be #Reviewer2
#Academiclife
0
0
0
0
Reviewer 2, the silence is deafening! 🧐 It’s been a month—any chance we’ll see those comments soon? ⏳ #PeerReview #AcademicChatter #Reviewer2
2
0
0
0
I’ve told the editorial assistant that I will revise, but not before the end of January at the earliest. But that turnaround is badly enough for proofs, let alone adding references to two new articles and/or completely rewriting the second half of the article! #reviewer2
2
0
1
0
This can feel uncomfortable at first because you want to show everyone that you are to be taken seriously. But I can't say it often enough: Keep your writing simple and clear.
Tune in to the Researchers' Writing Podcast and learn about the other scientific writing myths.
#researcher
#Reviewer2
2
0
0
0
If this was an article submission, #reviewer2 would say “research question is unclear; does not advance knowledge.”
www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/...
0
0
1
0
#Reviewer2 IRL
2
1
0
0
I’ll be sure to write a good paper next time, very helpful
#reviewer2
0
0
0
0
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Collage featuring a person in a red dress with gears, lightbulb, book, and laptop — representing knowledge sharing and peer review – and held aloft on a paper airplane by a giant hand.
Who’s afraid of #Reviewer2?
Journal editors @carinrunciman.bsky.social Sweta Rajan-Rankin @silkeroth.bsky.social and Maud Perrier demystify the much-maligned peer review process – and all the care, thought and reflection that goes into it – in the Magazine’s latest issue.
buff.ly/fekw1xq
5
1
0
0
Et on sait déjà de longue date que même #Reviewer2 ne lit pas votre article…
5
1
0
0
Now that I think of it, @lastpositivist.bsky.social has devised the perfect reply to every #Reviewer2 in the academia.
And they say that there is no progress in #philosophy... 😝
13
3
2
0
I am #Reviewer2 in a submission I was invited to #review. I will take the chance to stop the myth of the nasty comments of this reviewer. It is a myth, right, #AcademicSky?!
2
0
0
0