EXTRA INNINGS EDITOR GUIDE
Matthew Beckett was Rollins High’s golden boy—baseball MVP, town favorite, and completely unprepared for what he felt for Owen Hart. Owen was quiet, brilliant, and saw Matt more clearly than anyone ever had. Then an injury in the minor leagues ended Matt’s shot at going pro, and whatever future he’d imagined for himself slipped out of reach.
Fifteen years later, Matt is back in Rollins, coaching varsity baseball and barely keeping his footing as a high school history teacher. Owen never left. He’s built a steady, satisfying life as a beloved English teacher—out, confident, and deeply rooted in the community. The last thing he needs is Matt Beckett back in town.
When the principal asks Owen to mentor him, old instincts return with dangerous ease. What begins as professionalism gives way to late nights, shared glances, and a physical connection neither of them can pretend isn’t happening.
Matt is everything Owen remembers—driven, magnetic, and still standing at the edge of something Owen once let go. Owen won’t repeat the same mistake, even as hope insists that this time the choice might finally be easier.
baseball coach x english teacher
second chance with flashbacks
small town baseball culture
former hs teammates to colleagues
teach me how to...teach
the varsity baseball team
is rooting for them
The Tropes
The Comps
Baseball teaammates
+ Second Chance
Small town second chance + competence kink
FLASHBACKS
But they are BOTH teachers
One is chasing their dreams...the other worries its passed them by
they’re just figuring it out, okay?
When the guy who broke your heart in HS returns home and suddenly he's:
🍎 Teaching down the hall from you
⚾ Coaching Varsity Baseball
👨❤️💋👨 Hoping to kiss you in the coffee shop when you're supposed to be lesson planning...oops. It worked.
#CuPit #A #CR #LGBT #MHR